Can Michigan beat Texas? Big House showdown could have big College Football Playoff impact

ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Texas and Michigan have met only once, a game known as Vince Young’s second most famous Rose Bowl performance.

Michigan fans are haunted by memories of the Texas quarterback weaving through the Wolverines’ defense for 192 rushing yards and four touchdowns in the 2005 Rose Bowl, a 38-37 thriller won by the Longhorns on a field goal in the final seconds. Young returned to that end zone in Pasadena the following season with an iconic touchdown run that lifted Texas over USC and gave Mack Brown his only national championship.

In the years that followed, Michigan and Texas became emblematic of blue-blood programs that had lost their way. The Longhorns cycled through Charlie Strong and Tom Herman before hiring Steve Sarkisian. Michigan cycled through Rich Rodriguez and Brady Hoke before hiring Jim Harbaugh. After a long climb, the programs nearly met at the mountaintop last season, as Texas was a play away from beating Washington in the Sugar Bowl and facing Michigan in the championship game of the College Football Playoff.

Saturday, the No. 3 Longhorns and No. 10 Wolverines will meet in the first installment of a home-and-home series originally scheduled in 2014. In a fitting sign of the times, the location of Saturday’s game was flipped from Austin to Ann Arbor as part of exit negotiations when Texas and Oklahoma left the Big 12 for the SEC, which allowed Fox to broadcast the game in its marquee noon window. Now, Michigan’s 23-game home winning streak is on the line.

What happens Saturday will set the stage for CFP races in the Big Ten and SEC. A win over the Wolverines would entrench Texas as a CFP favorite, while an upset of the Longhorns would give Michigan a massive boost in its quest for a fourth consecutive CFP appearance. Postseason implications aside, the spectacle of two storied programs meeting at Michigan Stadium will be one of the high points of college football’s September schedule.

“It’s going to be a lot of people up here, all the TV crews,” Michigan cornerback Will Johnson said. “It’s going to be like Rose Bowls, Ohio State games, those types of games. I feel like that’s when we play our best football.”

Texas won its only meeting with Michigan in the 2005 Rose Bowl. (Donald Miralle / Getty Images)

Three matchups to watch

Mason Graham and Kenneth Grant vs. Texas’ offensive line. Texas has one of the top offensive lines in college football led by left tackle Kelvin Banks Jr., a first-team pick on The Athletic’s preseason All-America team. Michigan has two of the top interior linemen in the nation in Graham and Grant. Both players are being asked to play more snaps this season, and their ability to hold up in the fourth quarter will be crucial.

Colston Loveland vs. the Texas defense. Loveland was the top passing target of new Michigan quarterback Davis Warren against Fresno State with eight receptions for 87 yards and a touchdown. Michigan’s wide receivers didn’t put anything on film against Fresno State that’s going to scare an opposing defense, meaning it could be up to Loveland to find open space against a defense that’s going to be ready for the ball to come his way.

Wink Martindale vs. Steve Sarkisian. Football nerds will love the game within the game as these two play callers try to outfox each other. Martindale, a veteran NFL defensive coordinator in his first season at Michigan, has lots of ways to disrupt an offense. Sarkisian, one of the top offensive minds in college football, has lots of ways to put a defense on its heels. Expect both to have something in the bag to keep the other guessing.

GO DEEPER

Who is Davis Warren? Michigan’s new QB has a story bigger than Texas

What we’ll be talking about after the game

We’ll be talking about Michigan’s quarterbacks, of course. There’s also a good chance we’ll be talking about Donovan Edwards, who has a history of showing up in big games.

As proof, here are Edwards’ splits the past two years in games involving Top 25 opponents and games versus unranked opponents:

Edwards’ performance in the CFP championship game raised expectations for his senior season and helped him land on the cover of EA College Football 25 alongside Texas quarterback Quinn Ewers and Colorado’s Travis Hunter. But his performance against Fresno State resembled some of his early games last season, as Edwards struggled to find running lanes and finished with 27 yards on 11 carries.

Earlier this week, running backs coach Tony Alford said some of the same things we heard when Edwards was scuffling last season. Alford mentioned the importance of taking the yards that are available instead of trying to hit a home run on every carry and said he talked to Edwards after the game about keeping a positive demeanor when the long runs aren’t happening.

“Frustration? Sure. We all get frustrated at times,” Alford said. “You still have a responsibility to lead in a positive manner and keep going because people are going to be looking at you. How do you respond when things aren’t maybe going as well as you would like them to go personally? We did talk about that, and I’m very happy and pleased with the way he’s responded to that.”

Last season, Edwards didn’t get rolling until Michigan played Penn State in November, which happened to be the first game of the season against a ranked opponent. Maybe facing a top-five opponent in Week 2 will be what Edwards needs to get off to a better start.

“Nobody in this building is worried about Donovan Edwards and what lies ahead for him,” Alford said. “He’s going to be perfectly fine.”

GO DEEPER

After privately hurting, Michigan’s Donovan Edwards has his ‘fire’ back

3 questions with …

… Sam Khan Jr., The Athletic’s Texpert:

1. These teams were very close to meeting in last year’s CFP championship game. We know Michigan is a drastically different team from last year, but what about Texas? What’s the same and what’s different about the Longhorns?

There has been change but also a significant amount of carryover from the 2023 Texas roster to 2024. Steve Sarkisian noted there are 46 players who traveled to the Week 2 win at Alabama last year who will be making this trip. That’s more than half the travel roster. And many of them are in key positions like quarterback (Quinn Ewers), offensive line (four of five starters return and all five of this year’s starters traveled to Tuscaloosa last year), linebacker (super sophomore Anthony Hill and David Gbenda) and several players in the secondary, including their best player back there, Jahdae Barron.

But there is a lot of new. The entire offensive skill position group is new. The starting receivers, running back Jonathon Brooks and tight end Ja’Tavion Sanders are all in the NFL. So is the dynamic defensive tackle duo of T’Vondre Sweat and Byron Murphy that set the tone for Texas’ 2023 defense. Their best corner last year, Ryan Watts, is also in the league now. Replacing all those players was an important part of the offseason, whether it was addressed via the transfer portal (the receivers) or developing returnees for their bigger roles (defensive line).

Even with those changes, one thing that has helped Texas’ continuity is the coaching staff. The Longhorns have the same offensive, defensive and special teams coordinators that Sarkisian originally hired in 2021. There have been a few position coach changes, including two this offseason, but the staff stability and schematic consistency has been critical to Texas not taking steps backward.

2. Put yourself in the shoes of Michigan OC Kirk Campbell. How would you try to attack this Texas defense with a new starting quarterback and a new offensive line?

Don’t fear the Texas defensive front. Run right at it and make that unit prove it can stop the run game. Alfred Collins and Vernon Broughton, the players who succeeded Sweat and Murphy, are good, experienced players, but they aren’t as dominant as their predecessors — at least not yet. Michigan’s identity is the power run game. Stick with that until you have to adjust.

Colorado State didn’t run wild against the Longhorns last week, but the Rams did find some success as Justin Marshall finished with 106 yards and a 4.2 yards per carry average. Because of how explosive this Texas offense is, if I were Campbell, I’d aim to control the clock and minimize possessions. Grind it out and lean on your big men to win at the line of scrimmage.

3. What’s one thing Michigan has to do defensively to have a shot at slowing down this Texas offense?

Keep everything in front of them, which is easier said than done. Texas has a lot of speed on the perimeter. Isaiah Bond, Matthew Golden, Johntay Cook II and freshman Ryan Wingo are all explosive receivers who can take it the distance. Not getting beat over the top and minimizing big plays will be critical. That will start up front, with keeping Texas’ run game in check.

Sarkisian loves to build off the run with the play action passing game and the more success the Longhorns have in the run game, the more dangerous they are with shot plays down the field. If Michigan can shut down Jaydon Blue, Quintrevion Wisner and Jerrick Gibson early, the Wolverines will be less susceptible to Sarkisian’s efforts to stretch the field.

CFP implications

The Athletic’s model gives Texas an 80 percent chance to make the CFP and Michigan a 25 percent chance after Week 1 results. Per Austin Mock, a Texas victory would bump the Longhorns’ odds up to 88.2 percent and give them leeway to survive a loss to Oklahoma or Georgia in October. Losing to Michigan wouldn’t be devastating to Texas’ CFP chances, as the model would still give the Longhorns a 63 percent chance to earn a bid, but they’d have a slimmer margin for error in the SEC.

Michigan’s CFP chances would jump to 41.1 percent with a win and fall to 14 percent with a loss. The Wolverines have three other games against teams currently ranked in the Top 25: No. 13 USC on Sept. 21, No. 7 Oregon on Nov. 2 and No. 2 Ohio State on Nov. 30. An early loss doesn’t eliminate anybody in the era of the 12-team Playoff, but Michigan would need to win at least one of those games to have a shot.

Prediction

Texas 24, Michigan 17. Astute readers might notice that, just a week ago, I picked Michigan to beat Texas and finish 10-2. Now I’m flip-flopping and picking the Longhorns. What gives?

Well … we finally saw Michigan’s offense on the field instead of hearing about it secondhand. A good rule of thumb is to take every glowing preseason report and discount it by about 50 percent. I did that, but I still might have underestimated how difficult it would be for Michigan to replace its departed stars on offense.

Even with the elevated competition, I expect Michigan’s offense to look more dynamic against Texas. Sherrone Moore knows how to scheme up a run game that’s a headache for the other team to defend. But Michigan’s opener raised too many questions to answer in one week, and Texas is talented enough to exploit Michigan’s offensive limitations.

(Top photo of Gregory Shamus / Getty Images)