Crypto

When Is a Crypto Asset a Security? The SEC's 2026 Interpretation

In March 2026 the SEC and CFTC issued a joint interpretation of how securities law applies to crypto assets. Here is the legal test behind it, what changed from 2019, and what remains unsettled.

Wooden gavel and block on marble

On March 17, 2026, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued an interpretation of how federal securities laws apply to certain crypto assets, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) joined it. This article explains the legal test underneath, what the document says according to the agencies, and what it does not settle.

Why does the “security” label matter so much?

In the United States, a company that offers or sells a security generally must register the offering with the SEC or qualify for an exemption, and must follow disclosure and anti-fraud rules. Intermediaries such as exchanges and brokers that handle securities face their own registration duties. Assets that are instead treated as commodities fall mainly under the CFTC, whose role centers on derivatives markets and fraud and manipulation rules rather than on registering each product.

Because the two regimes impose very different obligations, whether a given token is a security has shaped lawsuits, product launches and exchange listings for years. The question is not decided by what a project calls its token. It turns on how the asset is offered and sold.

The Howey test in plain terms

Courts decide whether an arrangement is an “investment contract,” one kind of security, using a test from the Supreme Court case SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. According to a 2019 SEC staff framework, an investment contract exists when three elements are present:

  1. An investment of money. Buyers give value, which can be dollars, another digital asset or other consideration.
  2. A common enterprise. The staff said it had typically found this present in digital asset offerings, because buyers’ fortunes are tied to one another or to the promoter’s efforts.
  3. A reasonable expectation of profits from the efforts of others. This is usually the contested element. It asks whether buyers are counting on the essential managerial work of a promoter or other active participant.

The 2019 framework listed factors pointing each way. Factors suggesting a security included a promoter who develops or operates a network that is not yet fully functional, controls supply or supports the market price, or markets the asset as an investment. Factors pointing away included a fully developed network that holders can use immediately and an asset whose price tracks the goods or services it buys. The framework stressed that no single factor was decisive and that the list was not exhaustive.

That framework is no longer current. The SEC’s page for it now says it was withdrawn and superseded by the March 17, 2026 document, and that it was non-binding staff guidance, not a Commission rule.

What did the March 2026 interpretation do?

According to the SEC’s press release (number 2026-30), the interpretation sets out categories of crypto assets: digital commodities, digital collectibles, digital tools, stablecoins and digital securities. It also explains how a “non-security crypto asset,” meaning one that is not itself a security, may become subject to an investment contract, and how it may stop being subject to one. The release says it clarifies how securities laws apply to four activities: airdrops (free distributions of tokens), protocol mining, protocol staking and the wrapping of a non-security crypto asset.

The SEC’s page for the release lists it as an interpretive release, File No. S7-2026-09, and says it took effect and was published in the Federal Register on March 23, 2026. The SEC’s public summary names these activities without spelling out the conclusion for each, so readers who need those details should consult the full text of the release.

The categories at a glance

Category named by the SEC What the label signals
Digital commodities Named as a category
Digital collectibles Named as a category
Digital tools Named as a category
Stablecoins Named as a category; see how stablecoins hold a dollar peg
Digital securities The category whose name signals continued treatment as securities

The SEC’s press release names the categories but does not define each one in its summary, so the table lists names only; the formal definitions are in the release text.

Can an investment contract come to an end?

One of the most discussed ideas in the release is that the legal wrapper around an asset can be separate from the asset. The SEC says a non-security crypto asset can be sold as part of an investment contract, for example when buyers pay in reliance on an issuer’s promises to do essential managerial work, and that the investment contract can later end.

SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins said in the release that “investment contracts can come to an end,” and that “most crypto assets are not themselves securities.” Those are the Chairman’s characterizations, and the release presents them as the Commission’s interpretation, not as a court holding. An interpretive release does not bind a judge.

A practical consequence is worth separating from the headline. Law-firm commentary on the release says a later “separation” does not erase earlier violations, so a past offering that should have been registered is not retroactively cured. That reading comes from secondary commentary and is not confirmed in the SEC’s own summary, so it is best treated as unverified.

What does the CFTC’s role add?

The SEC says the CFTC joined the interpretation, and that the CFTC and its staff will administer the Commodity Exchange Act consistently with the SEC’s reading. The release encourages market participants to review the document to understand the jurisdictional line between the two agencies. CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig said in the release, “With today’s interpretation, the wait is over.”

Joint statements matter because the agencies have long been seen as dividing the territory unevenly: the SEC over securities, the CFTC over commodities and derivatives. A shared reading reduces the chance that one agency treats an asset one way while the other treats it differently, but only for as long as both agencies keep that position.

Is this the same as a law from Congress?

No. An interpretation states how an agency reads existing statutes. It can be revised by a later Commission, and it can be challenged in court. The SEC’s release itself describes the interpretation as complementing congressional work on a market structure framework, and Chairman Atkins called it “an important bridge” while Congress works on legislation.

Statutes work differently: a law passed by Congress and signed by the President sets definitions that agencies must follow, and agencies can only change them by rulemaking within the limits Congress set. The process is described in the explainer on how a bill becomes law. Published accounts of where crypto market structure bills stand in the Senate differ on when and why votes stalled, so the current status should be checked against official congressional records before relying on any one account.

What does it change for ordinary holders?

For a person who simply holds crypto, the interpretation mostly operates in the background. It affects whether platforms list certain assets, how issuers structure sales and how enforcement cases may be framed. It does not change how crypto is taxed; that is a separate question covered in how the IRS taxes crypto. It also does not create insurance: the question of what protects customer assets when a platform fails is separate from the securities classification.

Product design is another place the labels matter. The path by which a fund holding a digital asset reaches the market depends on exchange and SEC standards, as described in how spot crypto ETFs get listed. A clearer view of which assets are commodities rather than securities may shape those decisions, but each product still requires its own approvals.

What remains unresolved

Several things are still open as of November 2026:

  • Comment and refinement. The SEC’s release page links to a comment form for the file number, but the page does not state a deadline.
  • Rulemaking. Commentary from law firms describes possible further SEC rulemaking and a safe harbor under consideration. The SEC’s own summary does not confirm that, so it should be viewed as reported, not settled.
  • Courts. Judges apply the Howey test to the facts of each case. An agency’s interpretation can inform an argument, but it does not decide one.
  • Disputed history. Chairman Atkins said the interpretation “acknowledges what the former administration refused to recognize.” That is the Chairman’s characterization of the SEC’s earlier approach, and this article does not adopt it.

Reading the next announcement with care

The lasting lesson is the test, not any one agency’s current view of it. When a new announcement says an asset is or is not a security, three questions help: who issued it (a Commission, its staff, a court or Congress), whether it is binding, and what facts it assumes about how the asset was sold. Agencies can change positions, and a token’s classification can depend on promises made at the time of sale.

The March 2026 interpretation is a significant statement of the SEC’s and CFTC’s current reading. It is not a statute, it does not guarantee how a court will rule, and it says nothing about whether any asset is a good or bad idea to own.

This is general information about how securities and commodities rules apply to crypto assets. It is not personalized financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

Sources: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission