News

How Presidential Pardons and Clemency Work in the United States

The Constitution gives the president broad power to forgive federal offenses. Here is how pardons and commutations differ, how the Justice Department process runs, and what clemency does not do.

A large white building with a fountain in front of it

Presidential pardons often make headlines, but the machinery behind them is less familiar. This article explains where the power comes from, the difference between a pardon and a commutation, how the Justice Department reviews applications, and what a grant of clemency can and cannot change.

Where does the pardon power come from?

The power sits in Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution. According to the text held by the National Archives, the president “shall have Power to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.”

Three features of that sentence matter in practice:

  • It covers federal offenses. The clause refers to “Offences against the United States,” so it reaches federal crimes, not violations of state law.
  • It has one stated exception. Impeachment is carved out. Separately, the Constitution says judgment in impeachment cases “shall not extend further than to removal from Office,” and a person removed that way may still face ordinary criminal proceedings.
  • It sits with the president alone. Unlike a bill, which must pass both chambers (see how a bill becomes law), clemency needs no vote by Congress. The Justice Department’s Office of the Pardon Attorney says that “the President has the sole power to grant clemency.”

“Clemency” is the umbrella term for several kinds of relief. The Justice Department’s pages focus on two: pardons and commutations. Reprieves, which postpone a sentence, are also named in the constitutional text.

Pardon or commutation: what is the difference?

The two are often confused, but the Justice Department describes them differently.

Pardon Commutation
What it does Forgives the offense and removes remaining penalties and some legal disabilities Reduces a sentence that is being served, in whole or in part
Changes the conviction? The conviction stays on the record, alongside the pardon No
Typical timing Before conviction, before a sentence begins, or after it is finished After a sentence has begun
Civil disabilities May remove those imposed because of the conviction Does not remove them

According to the Department’s frequently asked questions page, a commutation can also include remission of unpaid criminal financial penalties, such as fines or restitution, but only the part not already paid. The Justice Manual adds that commutation “does not forgive the offense or change the conviction.”

What does a pardon actually change?

According to the Office of the Pardon Attorney, a pardon:

  • removes unserved or unpaid parts of a sentence;
  • removes civil disabilities that were imposed because of the conviction, such as limits on voting, holding state or local office, or serving on a jury;
  • can lessen the stigma of a conviction and may help with licenses, bonding or employment;
  • can restore federal firearms rights (the Attorney General can also do so under a separate statute, 18 U.S.C. § 925(c));
  • in some circumstances, can remove the legal basis for deportation.

The same page is equally clear about the limits. A pardon “does not signify innocence.” It does not erase the conviction, since both the conviction and the pardon remain on the record. It does not end non-criminal civil proceedings, such as civil forfeitures or civil actions by the IRS or the SEC. And in some states, restoring civil rights follows state procedures, so applicants are told to check with their state.

Expungement, meaning a court order sealing or destroying a record, is a different remedy altogether. According to the Department, it is a judicial remedy: federal requests go to the court of conviction, while state requests go to the governor or state attorney general.

What if the conviction was in state court?

The president cannot help. According to the Justice Department, clemency from the president applies only to federal offenses and to offenses under the District of Columbia Code that were prosecuted in D.C. Superior Court. People with state convictions are directed to the governor or the state board of pardons or paroles, if the state has one. The rules vary by state.

This split mirrors the broader division of the American court system, which is explained in federal courts versus state courts. A person’s first question is usually which government prosecuted the case, because that determines who can forgive it.

How does the application process work?

The Justice Department summarizes its role in a short phrase: it “investigates and recommends,” and the president decides. Applications go through the Office of the Pardon Attorney, which operates under federal regulations (28 C.F.R. parts 0 and 1).

The steps the Department describes are:

  1. Application. The applicant submits the right form for a pardon or a commutation, receives a case number, and can check the case status online. Updates, such as a new address, can be added while the case is pending.
  2. Department review. The Department investigates. For pardon requests it may ask the FBI for a background investigation, and in some cases it seeks comments from the U.S. Attorney and the sentencing judge. It then recommends how the president should act.
  3. Presidential decision. The president decides whether to grant or deny. Applicants are notified, and decisions are posted on the Office’s “Past Clemency Actions” page.

Two practical points stand out. First, the process is written. The Department states that no hearing is held on any application. Second, no lawyer is required, and the Department says most applicants do not have one. The office cannot provide legal advice.

What standards guide the recommendation?

The Justice Manual, the Department’s internal policy guide, sets out factors. They are guidance for the Department’s recommendation, and the president is not bound by them.

Pardons after a sentence is complete

According to the Justice Manual, petitioners generally must wait at least five years after conviction or release from confinement, whichever is later, though the Department may waive the requirement. Other factors include:

  • Conduct since conviction. A responsible, productive life over a significant period is described as “strong evidence of rehabilitation and worthiness for pardon.”
  • Seriousness and recency. Serious offenses, such as violent crimes, major drug trafficking, breaches of public trust or large-scale fraud, call for more time to have passed. Very old and relatively minor offenses may weigh more toward forgiveness.
  • Acceptance of responsibility. The manual says petitioners should seek forgiveness rather than vindication. Claims of innocence face “a formidable burden of persuasion.”
  • Harm and need. Effects on victims and on the public are weighed, and a specific need, such as removing a licensing barrier, can help, though its absence should not count against an applicant.

Commutations

The manual calls commutation “an extraordinary remedy.” Recognized grounds include sentence disparity or undue severity, critical illness or old age, and meritorious government service such as cooperation. Rehabilitation in custody or unforeseen emergencies may also support a request. Requests are generally not accepted until a person has begun serving the sentence, or from people still challenging the conviction or sentence in court. Officials also consider alternatives such as a Rule 35 motion (a request to correct or reduce a sentence), a fine-modification motion or a compassionate-release motion.

Can a denied applicant try again?

Yes, after a delay. The Department’s FAQ lists the only waiting periods it sets for reapplying after a denial: 12 months for a commutation and 24 months for a pardon, counted from the denial date. The FAQ does not set a minimum waiting period before someone can first apply for a pardon, although the Justice Manual’s five-year expectation applies to the post-sentence category described above.

Does everything go through the Justice Department?

Not necessarily. The Office of the Pardon Attorney’s own materials say Presidents have sought its advice for over 130 years, but the same page says the president “has the sole power to grant clemency.” Because the power is constitutional, it is not limited to applications that came through the Department. The Department’s FAQ confirms that the president can pardon people who have not yet been convicted or have not begun serving a sentence. How often a given president relies on the formal review, and how many grants it covers, varies by administration, and this article does not try to compare them.

The Justice Department’s statistics page reports totals by fiscal year, which begins October 1. Its most recent entry in the version available when this piece was prepared covered only a partial fiscal year, 2025, and was last updated in January 2025. Because such numbers depend on how petitions are counted and on timing, readers comparing administrations should consult the Department’s own tables directly.

What is still debated?

The text of the clause is short, and some questions are argued by legal scholars rather than settled by a single ruling. Examples that commonly arise include whether and how the power applies to the president’s own case, how far pardons can reach before any charge is filed, and whether accepting a pardon implies an admission of guilt. This article does not take a side on those questions. The primary government sources reviewed here, the Constitution and the Justice Department’s pages, do not resolve them, and a reader who wants the case law should turn to Supreme Court opinions and Congressional Research Service legal analysis.

What the sources do establish is the practical baseline: the power is the president’s alone, it reaches federal and D.C. offenses, and it works through a written process that begins with an application and ends with a decision that the president is free to make.

Clemency in short: one constitutional power, several kinds of relief

Presidential clemency is a narrow tool with a wide constitutional base. A pardon forgives; a commutation shortens. Neither is an expungement, and neither reaches state convictions. The Justice Department’s review is advisory, written and detailed, while the final choice rests with the president. Like executive orders, clemency is an example of power exercised directly by the president, though its limits and legal effects differ.

This article explains how a government process works and is general information, not legal advice or an endorsement of any decision. People with a specific conviction should consult a qualified attorney.

Sources: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of the Pardon Attorney; U.S. Department of Justice, Justice Manual; National Archives